Many people worry if doing gymnastics makes kids short. Research says it’s not that simple. Most studies do not find that gymnastics permanently stunts a child’s final adult height. While intense training can affect growth patterns temporarily, especially in elite athletes, genetics is still the main thing deciding how tall someone will be as an adult. Fears about permanent height stunting directly from the sport itself are often not supported by the facts.
Image Source: i.insider.com
The Height Question: What Research Shows
People often look at elite gymnasts and see they are typically smaller and shorter. This makes them wonder if the sport caused them to be short. Research has looked into this for many years. It tries to separate the effects of the sport from other things.
Final Adult Height
Studies often compare gymnasts to other athletes or to girls who don’t do intense sports. Some studies even compare gymnasts to their own sisters who didn’t do gymnastics.
Here is what some research on gymnastics and height suggests:
- Genetics is King: Most studies agree that how tall a child will be is mostly set by their parents’ height. This is the biggest factor.
- Similar Final Height: Many studies comparing former gymnasts to others find they reach a similar final adult height as expected based on their family. Even if they were shorter during their training years, they often catch up later. This suggests that does elite gymnastics stunt growth permanently is likely not true for most.
- Selection Bias: Part of why elite gymnasts are often small might be because people with naturally smaller and more compact bodies are better suited for the sport and are more likely to stick with it and reach the elite level. This is called selection bias. It means smaller kids are chosen for gymnastics, not made small by it.
- Research on Athletic Training and Height: Broader research on intense training in young athletes across different sports (not just gymnastics) also usually concludes that intense exercise itself does not lower final adult height, as long as nutrition is good and the athlete is healthy otherwise.
Growth Rates During Training
While final height might not be affected, research has sometimes shown that gymnasts might grow a little slower during the years they are training intensely.
- Temporary Slowing: Some studies observe that young gymnasts grow less in height during periods of very tough training compared to kids their age who are not training hard.
- Catch-Up Growth: However, this often seems to be a temporary slowdown. Once training lessens, or after they stop the sport, many gymnasts show “catch-up growth.” They grow faster for a time until they reach their expected adult height.
- Intense Training Effects on Child Development: This temporary slowdown isn’t unique to gymnastics. It can happen in other sports requiring high energy use and lean body types, especially if not managed well with rest and food.
Important Factors in Growth and Training
Growth in children is a complex process. It involves many things working together. Bones, hormones, food, and overall health all play a role. Intense sports can sometimes interact with these factors. Research looks at these specific areas to see how they might be linked to growth patterns in gymnasts.
Puberty and Hormones
Puberty is a time of big growth spurts. It’s controlled by hormones. Intense training can sometimes affect this timing.
- Delayed Puberty Gymnasts: It is true that some female gymnasts, especially at the elite level, experience delayed puberty. Their periods might start later than average.
- Hormonal Impact of Rigorous Exercise: High-level training, combined with possibly not eating enough calories to match the energy being used (called low energy availability), can affect the hormones that signal the body to start puberty.
- How it Links to Growth: Puberty is when the biggest growth spurt happens. If puberty is delayed, the growth spurt is also delayed. This means the child might be shorter than their friends for a while. But it doesn’t mean they won’t have a growth spurt later. Delayed puberty usually just shifts the growth timeline, it doesn’t typically reduce the final height.
Bone Health and Maturity
Bones are where growth happens, mainly at areas called growth plates. The strength and ‘age’ of bones are also important.
- Growth Plate Injuries: Growth plates are soft areas near the ends of long bones in children. They are where the bone adds length. Intense, repetitive forces, like those in gymnastics, can sometimes stress these areas. In rare cases, a severe injury to a growth plate can potentially affect how that specific bone grows, but most growth plate injuries heal well with rest and proper care and do not affect overall final height.
- Bone Density Benefits: On the positive side, the weight-bearing nature of gymnastics is generally very good for bone health in athletes. The forces help build strong bones, leading to higher bone density later in life, which is a good thing for preventing problems like osteoporosis as they get older.
- Skeletal Maturity Gymnasts: Doctors can look at X-rays to see how mature a child’s bones are. This is called skeletal age or bone age. It doesn’t always match their actual age (chronological age). Sometimes, intense training is linked to bones looking slightly older than the child’s age. This could, in theory, mean the growth plates close a little sooner. However, research is not clear that this significantly impacts the final adult height in most cases. It’s another area where the body is adapting, but not necessarily in a way that causes permanent stunting from the sport itself.
Energy Availability (Nutrition)
This is a very important factor often highlighted in recent research. It’s not just the training itself, but whether the child is getting enough fuel for the training and for growth.
- Fueling for Growth and Activity: Children need a lot of calories to grow, go through puberty, and do intense exercise. If they don’t eat enough to cover all these needs, the body has to save energy.
- Low Energy Availability: When calorie intake is too low compared to energy spent exercising, the body can reduce functions that use a lot of energy, like growth and reproduction (puberty).
- Link to Growth and Hormones: Not getting enough energy is strongly linked to slower growth rates, delayed puberty, and effects on bone health. This is a key part of the intense training effects on child development, particularly in demanding sports like elite gymnastics. This nutritional shortfall, rather than the jumps or skills themselves, is a more likely reason for temporary growth changes seen in some athletes.
Does Intensity Matter? Elite vs. Recreational
Not all kids doing gymnastics train the same way. A child doing gymnastics for fun a few hours a week is very different from an elite athlete training 30+ hours a week. Research points out that the level of intensity and commitment plays a big role in potential effects on the body.
Hours and Start Age
The amount of training and when a child starts specializing in one sport are factors looked at in research.
- High Training Volume: Athletes who train many hours per week, especially from a very young age, are the ones most likely to show some of the temporary effects mentioned earlier, like slower growth rate or delayed puberty. This is linked to the sheer intense training effects on child development under high demand.
- Risks of Early Sports Specialization: Focusing on just one sport intensely year-round from a young age (early specialization) can increase risks. These risks include overuse injuries (like to growth plates), burnout, and potential impacts on growth and maturation if not managed with proper recovery, nutrition, and overall health monitoring. This is why the question does elite gymnastics stunt growth is more relevant than asking if doing a recreational class does. The level of training is key.
- Recreational Gymnastics: For children doing gymnastics a few hours a week for fun and exercise, there is generally no research showing any negative impact on growth or development. In fact, the activity is typically beneficial for strength, coordination, and bone health.
Putting the Research Together
So, what does all the research tell us about the fear that gymnastics stunts growth? It gives us a clearer picture than just looking at the body types of top athletes.
Key Takeaways from Studies
- Final Height: Most studies do not support the idea that gymnastics causes permanent short stature. Final adult height is mainly determined by genetics.
- Temporary Effects: Intense training, especially in elite athletes with high hours, can be linked to temporary slowdowns in growth rate and delayed puberty.
- Contributing Factors: These temporary effects are often linked more to factors associated with intense training, such as low energy availability (not eating enough for the activity level), hormonal changes, and potentially stress on growth plates (though injuries usually heal well).
- Not Just Gymnastics: Similar growth pattern changes can sometimes be seen in other sports that involve intense training, high energy demands, and pressure to maintain a low body weight or specific body type.
- Selection Bias: The fact that many successful elite gymnasts are small might be more about smaller people being better suited to the sport and succeeding in it, rather than the sport making them small.
When Risks Might Increase
While gymnastics itself isn’t a direct cause of stunting, certain conditions surrounding intense training in the sport could potentially affect a child’s growth trajectory if not managed well.
Risks are higher when:
- Nutrition is Poor: The child is not getting enough calories, protein, and other nutrients to support their high energy needs plus their growth and development.
- Rest and Recovery are Lacking: The body doesn’t get enough time to repair and grow between tough training sessions. Overtraining can disrupt hormone balance.
- Injuries are Ignored: Especially if growth plate injuries are not given proper time to heal.
- Training Volume is Excessive: Very high hours at a young age without careful monitoring and management for overall health.
In these cases, the management of the training and the athlete’s health is more the issue than the sport’s movements themselves.
Looking After Young Athletes
Based on the research, the focus should be on supporting the child’s overall health and development while they participate in sports. This helps ensure they grow well and stay healthy, regardless of their sport.
Prioritizing Nutrition and Rest
- Fuel the Body: Make sure young athletes eat enough healthy food to support their activity levels and their growth. Work with a sports dietitian if needed, especially for elite athletes. Emphasize balanced meals and snacks.
- Ensure Enough Rest: Sleep is when much of growth and repair happens. Make sure children get adequate sleep. Schedule rest days from training. Avoid training through illness or severe fatigue.
Monitoring Growth and Health
- Regular Check-ups: Have the child’s growth (height and weight) checked regularly by a doctor. They can compare the child’s growth to typical growth charts and their own growth history.
- Listen to Their Body: Teach children to communicate how they feel. Pay attention to signs of fatigue, persistent pain, or lack of progress. Address potential issues like delayed periods with a doctor. Monitoring skeletal maturity gymnasts might be done by doctors in specific cases if there are growth concerns.
Balanced Training and Development
- Age-Appropriate Training: Ensure training plans are suitable for the child’s age and developmental stage. Avoid excessive hours or intensity for young children.
- Focus on Long-Term Health: The goal should be the child’s long-term well-being, not just short-term athletic success. Avoid the risks of early sports specialization by allowing time for other activities and interests, especially at younger ages.
- Overall Health: Encourage a positive body image. Avoid pressure regarding weight. Support mental health as well as physical health. This comprehensive approach supports better bone health in athletes and overall healthy growth.
Conclusion
The fear that gymnastics directly and permanently stunts growth is largely not supported by scientific research. While intense training, especially at the elite level, can be linked to temporary effects like slower growth rate and delayed puberty, these are often related to managing energy balance, hormones, and overall health under high physical demand. Genetics remains the primary determinant of final adult height.
For most children participating in gymnastics, particularly at recreational levels, the sport offers significant benefits for physical development, strength, and health. The key for young athletes in any demanding sport is careful management: ensuring proper nutrition, adequate rest, appropriate training volume, and prompt attention to health concerns. By prioritizing these aspects, parents and coaches can help young gymnasts pursue their sport while supporting their healthy growth and development.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
H4: Does recreational gymnastics affect height?
No, research shows that recreational gymnastics, typically involving fewer hours per week, does not negatively affect a child’s final adult height. The amount of activity is generally beneficial for overall health and bone development.
H4: Can delayed puberty from gymnastics affect final height?
Delayed puberty can mean a child is shorter during their teenage years because their growth spurt hasn’t happened yet. However, it usually just delays the growth timeline. The child often catches up later and reaches their expected adult height based on genetics. It doesn’t typically cause a shorter final height on its own.
H4: Are growth plate injuries common in gymnastics? Do they stunt growth?
Growth plate injuries can happen in gymnastics due to repetitive stress or acute trauma, but they are not extremely common. Most growth plate injuries heal well with proper medical care and rest. They usually do not affect final bone length or overall height unless they are severe, complex, or not treated correctly, which is rare.
H4: Why are elite gymnasts often short?
This is likely due to a combination of factors, mainly genetics and selection bias. Children who are naturally smaller and more compact are often better suited for the physical demands of elite gymnastics and are more likely to excel and continue in the sport. The sport doesn’t usually make them short; they may have been predisposed to a smaller stature.
H4: What is more important for growth: genetics or training?
Genetics is by far the most important factor determining a person’s final adult height. While very intense training combined with poor nutrition and lack of rest can temporarily affect growth patterns or timing, it doesn’t typically override the strong influence of genetics on final height.
H4: How can parents support healthy growth in a child doing intense gymnastics?
Focus on providing plenty of healthy food to meet their high energy needs, ensure they get enough sleep and rest days, monitor their growth with a doctor, and listen to their body regarding pain or fatigue. A balanced approach to training that avoids over-specialization too early can also help.